Papurau Newydd Cymru

Chwiliwch 15 miliwn o erthyglau papurau newydd Cymru

Cuddio Rhestr Erthyglau

8 erthygl ar y dudalen hon

I Merthyr Hospital Deadlock.…

Newyddion
Dyfynnu
Rhannu

I Merthyr Hospital Deadlock. I 't r Prompt Rejection of Workmen's Proposals. 44 Build Your Own Institution." I Organised Labour's Alternative. 1 That the terms upon which the workmen of he Borough were prepared to pay zL2,800 fear or thereabouts towards the Merthyr General Hospital should be turned down occa- ionsno surprise. Their rejection by the special Meeting of the court of Govei-liors of the insti- tution held on Thursday evening was quite an rfiticipated event. A virile hostility to the porkers' proposals was apparent from the com fen cement of the proceedings which eulminated 11 an unqualified challenge to the workmen to Pound, if they would not accept the Executive board's terms, an institution of their own. Taking the, numbeTs revealed by the ballots the various proposals there were 151 governors present, an almost unprecedented at- tendance, whipped, no doubt, by the attention 4tawn in the convening notice by the autocratic to the" vital importance of opposing the Workmen's proposals." If these are carried, continued this interesting circular letter, the r%ult will be that the entire management and ?ntrol of the hospital will be taken over by the Workmen, as their representatives on the board kill be increased from six to eighteen, and the j^ce-presidents (with one exception) and the honorary medical staff (with three exceptions) •ill be excluded from the Executive Board. In- asmuch as the workmen have contributed ^tiling to the building and endowment fund of ;he hospital, which amount to a sum of £ 50,000 I,their sole contribution being about £ 2,500 to- wards equipment) we ask the governors to reject \:ho proposal as being unjust and unnecessary and |pt made in the real interests of the hospital. ?o allegation has been made against the Execu-' te Board of mismanagement, and they have ?th the funds available carried on the hospital tID the satisfaction of subscribers and patients have been located there. From the sub- 'oijxmittee'g report it wiU he seen that a pro- sal was made by the Executive Board to "Ouble the representation of the workmen in con- deration of the increased contributions, but hat was rejected by them, and representation ? 18 insisted upon, together with the elimina- :?< of all the vice-presidents except one. These f?-presidents have generally contributed to e funds of the hospital a.nd have been life Governors since the hospital was founded." Ool. J. J. Jones, J.P., the president, was Airman of the meeting, and expressed a hope ?t though, no doubt, there would be sharp ^isions of opinion between factions, nothing ^p*uld be "said or done that might ^reate ill- jehng or bitterness. ORKERS OUT FOR CONTROL. l After some quibbling as to how the resolutions Wild be put, Mr. T. J. Evans (Merthyr miners) 08e to the piece de resistance" of the work- ,ell's proposals, its adoption being seconded by Eben Jones (Dowlais miners). The resolution embodied that in return for a bc,cription of 4s. per annum per workman (and for lads under eighteen) the Executive Board 36 should consist of eighteen workmen's re- ^esentatives with the limitation of the re- mainder to three representatives of the medical I,tta.ff one each to Mswsrs. Guest, Keen and Net- ilefolds Crawshay Brothers, Hills-Plymouth Co. t!ld Nixon's Navigation, eight selected by the tyirt of governors and a seat each for the Presi- e1!lt, vice-president and treasurer. This, said Mr. EVans, was the culmination of j ■ series of attempts made by the workers to litlng about the democratisation of the hospital government and the agitation originated with request of the Executive Board for addi- al°ttal monetary aid. But, strange to say, that IDpeal was not accompanied by a promise or Suggestion of increased Labour representation. he workers were agreeable fully realising the r.gent necessity of funds, but their agreement conditional upon adequate representation, Justifying the reasonableness of the pro- Ials, he pointed out that, these conditional de- alids were endorsed by mass meetings of work- i.l1 and not engineered by a few. Their recep- tiOn by the Executive Board, however, was far t,otn enthusiastic. Workmen insisted on half e representation of the Executive Board be- Ilse they it was who needed the hospital—men 'a,ged in life-endangered occupations and na- l'ny they were concerned about the welfare of their class and because, too, under the proposed lCa.le of contributions the workers would be pay- threS-fourths of the maintenance cost of the stitntion. The" four-shilling" basis was not '0:0 high: he ventured to say that even more p^ uld be cheerfully given if necessa,ry-("Hear, ÍI'a;r," from Labour representatives)—but al- 1'Ys provisionally upon adequate representa- ;n. Bluntly he admitted the workmen were Ut for the hospital control, even to this extent: they paid the whole of the cost they should nhtled to the whole of the representation, r the year HH6 the maintenance of the insti- amounted to C31990, £ 1,700 of which only s derived from contributions. When it was ?embered that the quota asked for from the b?kmen was ?,800 it would be readily ad- "?d their • claim for half representation was i4fit extravagant, but rather particularly mode"t. groover, this £ 2,800 a ye?r calculated out upon e-,?tima d number of 11,000 men  in the krious industries concerned, in hj, opanion, was ??kil UndeT-estimate; there were more like 18,000 ?*ganised workers and even further unorganised l?ig,e-e,a,rr-ers might be persuaded to contribute I ill proper control w?re acceded them. IORST HOSPITAL IN THE KINGDOM." I t, A medico had described the institution to him j, the worst hospital in the kingdom, and true it ^as in his (the speaker's) opinion that it had I kept pace with the growing needs of the ?ough. The only way out of the dimculty was t)?? the workmen's proposals; without their con- 'ilbli?tions nothing could be done. If the 't O,t,ke?rs were conn dent of being adequately re- ?s?nted in its government the hospital had a 4 ?ht future? otherwise, none. ?assiiag on he vouchsafed nothing but praise 1'" e existing medica,! staS, but denied the v «dity of their claim each to a seat on the ^utive Board, by virtue of their ho»or<ary P-nts? illustrating his remarks by draw- J h ing parallels with the management of the Cardiff IInfirma.ry, where the medicos were represented l?b,-v five, and Aberdare Hospital, where the" re- presentatives allowed numbered three. EXECUTIVE'S PROPOSALS EXPLODED. Next he dealt with the counter-proposals of the Executive Board, in offering terms which on appea,ranee.s allowed the workmen twelve repre- sentatives (instead of the existing six) on a board of twenty-two. But to that number must be added twenty-one vice-presidents, eleven doc- tors and the president and treasurer, making a membership of 56. And as honourable men they could not, with any vestige of dignity, accept such terms—quarter representation for more than half monetary maintenance. Shortly the refusal of the demands of the workers would mean the future of the' hospital would be even more than the past, their accep- tance assured success. Mr. Eben Jones, seconding, appealed for the adoption of the proposals so that sufficient ac- commodation (now restricted by lack of funds) might be accorded the injured in the liosp-ital-- that, a helping hand might be extended the man on the stretcher," all too often of late compelled to enter the workhouse infirmary when cut down in his perilous calling and stig- matised by unsolicited pauperism. (" Shame.") Mr. F. T. James moved as an amendment the total rejection of the resolution, doing so (he said) only with great reluctance. After recapi- tulating the story of the foundation of the hospital lie declared that, although 95 per cent. of its advantages had been enjoyed by the workers during the 30 years of its existence their contributions were infiinitesimal. Defend- ing the Executive Board's counter-proposals as reasonable," he objected to the interpreta,tion put upon them by Mr. Evans, who knew quite well that with the exception of about 5 per cent. all the vice-presidents lived without tke Bor- ough and never attended a board meeting. It was absurd. WORKMEN'S ALTERNATIVE. u It is not reasonable for you to come here to-day and say Hand over this hospital! You have your remedy. Yon are strong enough. You have funds enough for a hospital of your own. That, I say, is a reasonable solution. This is a general hospital forevery class of the commu- nity, and therefore if you workmen have the funds and energy, build your own hospital and maintain and control it," he concluded. The amendment was seconded when Mr. T. J. Evans asked leave to contradiet the statement respecting the "infinitesimal" con- tributions of the workmen, by comparison with the donations of other contributors, but after a few ineffectual attempts to speak sat dpwn, ruled out of order by the chairman. On a card vote, the resolution was loet by 104 to 47. The second of the workmen's resolutions— that the honorary medical staff should be formed of all panel doctors in the area served by the hospital: a principal after two years' residence and an assistant after five years' residence in the district—was moved by Mr. Wm. Jones (Merthyr miners) and seconded by Mr. Tom Powell (Dowlais miners) only to be promptly op- posed by Dr. Cresswell (Dowlais) as (so he main- tained) absolutely unworkable in an institution of the size of the General Hospita. Put to the meeting the resolution was negatived. Mr. Lewis Jones (Dowlais miners) moved, and Mr. B. J. Williams (Merthyr miners) seconded the last of the workers' proposals, viz.: Small bodies of workmen or societies subscribing the sum of £ 5 per annum should be entitled to ap- point a governor. Mr. Jones pointed out that there were a considerable number of such bodies which would contribute liberally on these terms and added that so far as the Dowlais miners were concerned they had not received what they expected from the Executive Board for their L,900 a year subscriptions. CHALLENGE ACCEPTED. Mr. B. J. Williams took up Mr. James' chal- lenge. In future he hoped it would not be neces- sary for them to come begging on bended knee to people better circumstanced than themselves. He anticipated that the workers would quickly organise themselves in the creating of an institu- tion of their own. A tie in voting—53 for and against—'being declared, the chairman gave his casting vote against the resolution. Mr. D. W. Jones moved the resolution of the "other side" that the workmen at the Dowlaie works should, so long as they subscribed an- nually a sufficient sum to cover the cost of the maintenance of one bed, be entitled to nominate five governors; and if sufficient for two beds or more, three additional governors. The workmen of the Cyfarthfa, Plymouth and Merthyr Vale works should receive similar representation the condition being that there must be a subscription amounting to sufficient to cover the cost ( £ 100) of a bed before any nomination from any one of the works could be made. Mr. Jones said that it was obvious that the rule (Law No. 5) must be amended to the above terms to meet the ad- vance in the annual maintenance of a bed from £ 50 to £100. Mr. B. J. Williams pointed out that the.oper- ation of the amended rule suggested upon the workers' representation would be that if R400 were contributed instead of having 15 governors they would only be entitled to eight. Here thev found a type of Prussianism alike to the Ger- man variety. Of course, the workers were per- fectly aware of the opposition's power, but sooner c, later that would have to be met. The turning down of the workmen's proposals would damn the hospital's future. The motion having been seconded, it was car- ried by 57 votes tto 40.

Advertising

I Trade Union Notes.

Dowlais Notes.

Advertising

The I.L.P. at Kenfig Hill.

Advertising

Pontycymmer Notes.